Format no format

src/GitVersion.Core.Tests/Formatting/BackwardCompatibilityTests.cs

@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+namespace GitVersion.Core.Tests.Formatting;
+
+[TestFixture]
+public class LegacyRegexPatternTests
+{
+    [Test]
+    public void ExpandTokensRegex_ShouldParseLegacySemicolonSyntax()
+    {
+        const string input = "{CommitsSinceVersionSource:0000;;''}";
+
+        var matches = RegexPatterns.Common.ExpandTokensRegex().Matches(input);
+
+        matches.Count.ShouldBe(1);
+        var match = matches[0];
+        match.Groups["member"].Value.ShouldBe("CommitsSinceVersionSource");
+        match.Groups["format"].Success.ShouldBeTrue();
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    public void ExpandTokensRegex_ShouldHandleMixedSyntax()
+    {
+        const string input = "{NewStyle:0000 ?? 'fallback'} {OldStyle:pos;neg;zero}";
+
+        var matches = RegexPatterns.Common.ExpandTokensRegex().Matches(input);
+
+        matches.Count.ShouldBe(2);
+
+        var newMatch = matches[0];
+        newMatch.Groups["member"].Value.ShouldBe("NewStyle");
+        newMatch.Groups["fallback"].Value.ShouldBe("fallback");
+
+        var oldMatch = matches[1];
+        oldMatch.Groups["member"].Value.ShouldBe("OldStyle");
+    }
+}

src/GitVersion.Core.Tests/Formatting/DateFormatterTests.cs

@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 using System.Globalization;
 using GitVersion.Formatting;
 
-namespace GitVersion.Tests.Formatting;
+namespace GitVersion.Core.Tests.Formatting;
 
 [TestFixture]
 public class DateFormatterTests

src/GitVersion.Core.Tests/Formatting/LegacyFormatterProblemTests.cs

@@ -0,0 +1,163 @@
+using GitVersion.Core.Tests.Helpers;
+using GitVersion.Formatting;
+
+namespace GitVersion.Core.Tests.Formatting;
+
+[TestFixture]
+public class LegacyFormatterProblemTests
+{
+    private TestEnvironment environment;
+
+    [SetUp]
+    public void Setup() => environment = new TestEnvironment();
+
+    // ==========================================
+    // PROBLEM 1: Non-existent properties
+    // ==========================================
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Problem2")]
+    public void Problem2_NullValue_ShouldUseZeroSection()
+    {
+        var testObject = new { Value = (int?)null };
+        const string template = "{Value:positive;negative;zero}";
+        const string expected = "zero";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, environment);
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected, "Null values should use zero section without transformation");
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Problem1")]
+    public void Problem1_MissingProperty_ShouldFailGracefully()
+    {
+        // Test tries to use {MajorMinorPatch} on SemanticVersion but that property doesn't exist
+        var semanticVersion = new SemanticVersion
+        {
+            Major = 1,
+            Minor = 2,
+            Patch = 3
+        };
+
+        const string template = "{MajorMinorPatch}"; // This property doesn't exist on SemanticVersion
+
+        // Currently this will throw or behave unexpectedly
+        // Should either throw meaningful error or handle gracefully
+        Assert.Throws<ArgumentException>(() => template.FormatWith(semanticVersion, environment));
+    }
+
+    // ==========================================
+    // PROBLEM 2: Double negative handling  
+    // ==========================================
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Problem2")]
+    public void Problem2_NegativeValue_ShouldNotDoubleNegative()
+    {
+        var testObject = new { Value = -5 };
+        const string template = "{Value:positive;negative;zero}";
+
+        // EXPECTED: "negative" (just the literal text from section 2)
+        // ACTUAL: "-negative" (the negative sign from -5 plus the literal "negative")
+        const string expected = "negative";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, environment);
+
+        // This will currently fail - we get "-negative" instead of "negative"
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected, "Negative values should use section text without the negative sign");
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Problem2")]
+    public void Problem2_PositiveValue_ShouldFormatCorrectly()
+    {
+        var testObject = new { Value = 5 };
+        const string template = "{Value:positive;negative;zero}";
+        const string expected = "positive";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, environment);
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected);
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Problem2")]
+    public void Problem2_ZeroValue_ShouldUseZeroSection()
+    {
+        var testObject = new { Value = 0 };
+        const string template = "{Value:positive;negative;zero}";
+        const string expected = "zero";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, environment);
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected);
+    }
+
+    // ==========================================
+    // PROBLEM 3: Insufficient formatting logic
+    // ==========================================
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Problem3")]
+    public void Problem3_NumericFormatting_AllSectionsShouldFormat()
+    {
+        // Test that numeric formatting works in ALL sections, not just first
+        var testObject = new { Value = -42 };
+        const string template = "{Value:0000;0000;0000}"; // All sections should pad with zeros
+
+        // EXPECTED: "0042" (absolute value 42, formatted with 0000 in negative section)
+        // ACTUAL: "0000" (literal text instead of formatted value)
+        const string expected = "0042";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, environment);
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected, "Negative section should format the absolute value, not return literal");
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Problem3")]
+    public void Problem3_FirstSectionWorks_OthersDont()
+    {
+        // Demonstrate that first section works but others don't
+        var positiveObject = new { Value = 42 };
+        var negativeObject = new { Value = -42 };
+
+        const string template = "{Value:0000;WRONG;WRONG}";
+
+        // First section (positive) should work correctly
+        var positiveResult = template.FormatWith(positiveObject, environment);
+        positiveResult.ShouldBe("0042", "First section should format correctly");
+
+        // Second section (negative) should return literal when invalid format provided
+        var negativeResult = template.FormatWith(negativeObject, environment);
+        // Invalid format "WRONG" should return literal to give user feedback about their error
+        negativeResult.ShouldBe("WRONG", "Invalid format should return literal to indicate user error");
+    }
+
+    // ==========================================
+    // VERIFY #4654 FIX STILL WORKS
+    // ==========================================
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Issue4654")]
+    public void Issue4654_LegacySyntax_ShouldStillWork()
+    {
+        // Verify the original #4654 fix still works
+        var testObject = new { CommitsSinceVersionSource = 2 };
+        const string template = "{CommitsSinceVersionSource:0000;;''}";
+        const string expected = "0002";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, environment);
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected, "Issue #4654 fix must be preserved");
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    [Category("Issue4654")]
+    public void Issue4654_ZeroValue_ShouldUseEmptyString()
+    {
+        // Zero values should use the third section (empty string)
+        var testObject = new { CommitsSinceVersionSource = 0 };
+        const string template = "{CommitsSinceVersionSource:0000;;''}";
+        const string expected = "";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, environment);
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected, "Zero values should use third section (empty)");
+    }
+}

src/GitVersion.Core.Tests/Formatting/LegacyFormattingSyntaxTests.cs

@@ -0,0 +1,138 @@
+using System.Globalization;
+using GitVersion.Core.Tests.Helpers;
+using GitVersion.Formatting;
+
+namespace GitVersion.Core.Tests.Formatting;
+
+[TestFixture]
+public class LegacyFormattingSyntaxTests
+{
+    [Test]
+    public void FormatWith_LegacyZeroFallbackSyntax_ShouldWork()
+    {
+        var semanticVersion = new SemanticVersion
+        {
+            Major = 6,
+            Minor = 13,
+            Patch = 54,
+            PreReleaseTag = new SemanticVersionPreReleaseTag("gv6", 1, true),
+            BuildMetaData = new SemanticVersionBuildMetaData()
+            {
+                Branch = "feature/gv6",
+                VersionSourceSha = "versionSourceSha",
+                Sha = "489a0c0ab425214def918e36399f3cc3c9a9c42d",
+                ShortSha = "489a0c0",
+                CommitsSinceVersionSource = 2,
+                CommitDate = DateTimeOffset.Parse("2025-08-12", CultureInfo.InvariantCulture)
+            }
+        };
+
+        const string template = "{MajorMinorPatch}{PreReleaseLabelWithDash}{CommitsSinceVersionSource:0000;;''}";
+        const string expected = "6.13.54-gv60002";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(semanticVersion, new TestEnvironment());
+
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected);
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    public void FormatWith_LegacyThreeSectionSyntax_ShouldWork()
+    {
+        var testObject = new { Value = -5 };
+        const string template = "{Value:positive;negative;zero}";
+        const string expected = "negative";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, new TestEnvironment());
+
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected);
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    public void FormatWith_LegacyTwoSectionSyntax_ShouldWork()
+    {
+        var testObject = new { Value = -10 };
+        const string template = "{Value:positive;negative}";
+        const string expected = "negative";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, new TestEnvironment());
+
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected);
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    public void FormatWith_LegacyZeroValue_ShouldUseThirdSection()
+    {
+        var testObject = new { Value = 0 };
+        const string template = "{Value:pos;neg;ZERO}";
+        const string expected = "ZERO";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, new TestEnvironment());
+
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected);
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    public void FormatWith_MixedLegacyAndNewSyntax_ShouldWork()
+    {
+        var testObject = new
+        {
+            OldStyle = 0,
+            NewStyle = 42,
+            RegularProp = "test"
+        };
+        const string template = "{OldStyle:pos;neg;''}{NewStyle:0000 ?? 'fallback'}{RegularProp}";
+        const string expected = "0042test";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, new TestEnvironment());
+
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected);
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    public void FormatWith_LegacyWithStandardFormatSpecifiers_ShouldWork()
+    {
+        var testObject = new { Amount = 1234.56 };
+        const string template = "{Amount:C2;(C2);'No Amount'}";
+        const string expected = "¤1,234.56";
+
+        var actual = template.FormatWith(testObject, new TestEnvironment());
+
+        actual.ShouldBe(expected);
+    }
+
+    [Test]
+    public void FormatWith_Issue4654ExactCase_ShouldWork()
+    {
+        var semanticVersion = new SemanticVersion
+        {
+            Major = 6,
+            Minor = 13,
+            Patch = 54,
+            PreReleaseTag = new SemanticVersionPreReleaseTag("gv6", 1, true),
+            BuildMetaData = new SemanticVersionBuildMetaData("Branch.feature-gv6")
+            {
+                CommitsSinceVersionSource = 2
+            }
+        };
+
+        var mainBranchVersion = new SemanticVersion
+        {
+            Major = 6,
+            Minor = 13,
+            Patch = 54,
+            PreReleaseTag = new SemanticVersionPreReleaseTag(string.Empty, 0, true),
+            BuildMetaData = new SemanticVersionBuildMetaData()
+            {
+                CommitsSinceVersionSource = 0
+            }
+        };
+
+        const string template = "{MajorMinorPatch}{PreReleaseLabelWithDash}{CommitsSinceVersionSource:0000;;''}";
+
+        var featureResult = template.FormatWith(semanticVersion, new TestEnvironment());
+        featureResult.ShouldBe("6.13.54-gv60002");
+
+        var mainResult = template.FormatWith(mainBranchVersion, new TestEnvironment());
+        mainResult.ShouldBe("6.13.54");
+    }
+}

src/GitVersion.Core.Tests/Formatting/StringFormatterTests.cs

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 using GitVersion.Formatting;
 
-namespace GitVersion.Tests.Formatting;
+namespace GitVersion.Core.Tests.Formatting;
 
 [TestFixture]
 public class StringFormatterTests

src/GitVersion.Core.Tests/Formatting/ValueFormatterTests.cs

@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 using System.Globalization;
 using GitVersion.Formatting;
 
-namespace GitVersion.Tests.Formatting;
+namespace GitVersion.Core.Tests.Formatting;
 
 [TestFixture]
 public class ValueFormatterTests