Skip to content

Commit f07473d

Browse files
committed
docs: Add comprehensive analysis of issue #3126 and PR #3113 review
This analysis reviews the callback system refactoring proposal, identifying: - Code duplication claims (validated as accurate) - Proposed solution design (well-implemented with minor concerns) - Breaking change risk (removal of canonical_*_callbacks properties) - Unused code (CallbackExecutor not utilized due to signature mismatches) - Testing gaps (no integration test verification) Recommendation: Request changes before merging - Must fix: Add deprecation warnings instead of removing properties - Must fix: Verify existing callback tests pass - Should fix: Remove or document unused CallbackExecutor class Overall: Excellent first contribution with high-quality implementation, pending resolution of API compatibility and testing verification.
1 parent e0e5384 commit f07473d

File tree

2 files changed

+628
-0
lines changed

2 files changed

+628
-0
lines changed

analysis/README.md

Lines changed: 30 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
1+
# Code Analysis Materials
2+
3+
This directory contains detailed analyses and reviews of issues, pull requests, and code quality improvements for the ADK Python project.
4+
5+
## Contents
6+
7+
- **[issue-3126-pr-3113-review.md](./issue-3126-pr-3113-review.md)** - Comprehensive review of callback system refactoring
8+
- Issue: #3126 - Code duplication in callback system
9+
- PR: #3113 - Refactor callback system to eliminate code duplication
10+
- Status: Pending maintainer review
11+
- Recommendation: Request changes (deprecation + test verification needed)
12+
13+
## Review Process
14+
15+
Each analysis follows this structure:
16+
17+
1. **Root Cause Analysis** - Understanding the problem
18+
2. **Proposed Solution Review** - Evaluating the implementation
19+
3. **Impact Analysis** - Breaking changes, performance, maintainability
20+
4. **Recommendations** - Actionable next steps for contributors and maintainers
21+
5. **Conclusion** - Summary and final verdict
22+
23+
## Contributing
24+
25+
When adding new analyses:
26+
27+
1. Create a new branch: `analysis/issue-XXXX-description`
28+
2. Add markdown file: `issue-XXXX-analysis.md`
29+
3. Update this README
30+
4. Commit and push for future reference

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)